I spoke into his eyes… I thought you died alone; A long long time ago..
Ah penat lah. Lagu lain takde?
I thought you liked this song?
Some songs are tired. Macam aku. Aku penat.
*****

The Good Shepherd starts slowly, but I think it ended with a bang. It asks the question, at what price, patriotism? The central character in the movie, played by Matt Damon, could full well be one of the characters in the movie that won the Oscar for the Best Foreign Language Film of the Year, Das Leben der Anderen: The Lives of Others. Hannah Booth recently interviewed those jailed for various offences in the old East Germany who have read their secret Stasi files.
Jurgen Breitbarth, now 52, was spied on for the secret police by his best friend. Decades later, when they finally met again, his friend maintains that if he hadn’t been “keeping an eye on me” Breitbarth would have gone to prison a lot sooner. He said that he was protecting me, Breitbarth relates. I don’t know who his friend was trying to appease. A strong suspicion I have is that his friend is telling himself more than anyone else; as if telling yourself a million times would ever dull the knowledge inside the deepest of deep hearts, that you betrayed someone you loved. Breitbarth says he has moved on. I don’t think his friend will ever be able to, properly.
The Good Shepherd also told me another story, of cock-ups and mistakes made by the American government in the Cold War. And how, upon reflection, they choose to never learn from these mistakes. Like Vietnam before it, in a few years Iraq and Afghanistan would end up barren and impoverished, a function of mistakes made but denied, and its American legacy would lie in the slew of movies made depicting the mistakes of the past administration in the Middle East. But no lessons are to be taken from it. It will merely remain as an expression of art. Because even though they say, history is there for us to learn from, to guide us from repeating mistakes of the past; they perhaps forgot to add the caveat that history doesn’t matter, if you’re big enough to get away with it and write history yourself, any way you like it.

