Did we really need Australian researchers to tell us this?
Students in Malaysia spend an average of 3.8 hours a day in homework and this is a waste of time, according to a group of Australian principals and researchers. They say homework should be scrapped for children up to Form Three level because it robs kids of their childhood, causes arguments in families and does nothing to improve achievement.
This is the opinion of leading adolescent psychologist Michael Carr-Gregg, who is backed by the Victorian Association of State Secondary Principals and Australian Council for Educational Research. The average hours of homework each day in other countries include two for Australia, Canada (2.2), Iran (four), Italy (3.6), Japan (1.7), New Zealand (two), Russia (3.1), Singapore (3.5) and the US (2.1).
Full text here
This thought must have crossed the minds of researchers in education in Malaysia more than once. Are our kids spending too many hours doing homework, and going to tuition? Even parents gripe about this. And yet, I don’t recall a key Malaysian newspaper carrying results of a similar study in recent years (Please correct me if I am wrong, because I would be so much more relieved if I was!)
Which brings me to four questions:
a) Because most of our researchers, when they do their PhD, are sponsored by the government, do they not ask questions that may upset the balance of the system, of which homework is an integral part of? Because substantial findings would mean a need to rethink the education system, and may upset some people, and we don’t want to upset a Dato’, do we?
b) Are our researchers doing similar work and have found findings, but the media is generally not interested in research findings if it does not involve the sciences? Or do they not feel that Malaysian research is credible?
c) Are Malaysian researchers, and by this I mean those with a doctorate working at universities, doing any research, post-PhD? Or are we still holding the ‘bunga manggar’ even with an extra prefix in front of our names?
d) Is less homework better? Japan is lowest here (1.7 hours a day); but while their nation is indeed progressive, the state of their youth today leaves a lot to be desired for. Ash blogged about this earlier in the month, as an example.
————
Other links:
Scrap Homework, say principals – Herald Sun
Addendum:
————-
The other side of the coin – parents still believe homework is the way to success.
Ibu mahukan kerja rumah lebih – Utusan Malaysia